Thanksgiving weekend is lost to many seniors and their families who find themselves buried alive with college paperwork. Some are just starting to look at schools at this late date! Others are making their final choices and being shocked to find many with 12/1 scholarship deadlines. Still others are wading their way through applications. Depending on the academic rigor of the college or university, students find themselves with as many as five essays to write for a single school. That late realized fact turns a long weekend off school into a busier time than when school is in session.
Other families wait even longer, and find their Christmas Break overtaken with applications. Then they realize that there are financial aid applications, too. It's a recipe for disaster! It's also a recipe which won't yield the best outcome. Rushed applications don't include the students' best representations of themselves. Mistakes are made. Transcripts and recommendations and test scores are forgotten, or much delayed.
In contrast to that, as of this morning, most of my clients have been accepted at between one and four colleges and they have over $200,000 in scholarship monies already offered to them. They enjoyed Thanksgiving break and are looking forward to finishing their applications (for the few not already done) over Christmas break. They are already started; they just didn't finish them because of finals. But they aren't worried. They have been steadily working at their applications for the schools which made it onto their final schools list. And they have a time-tested college planner reviewing their essays and completed applications before they gather together to whisper a prayer and hit submit.
If you want peaceful holidays, it takes time and planning, and a little investment - with a fantastic ROI. 'Tis the season for gift giving. Give the sophomores and juniors in your life the gift of peace. Give us a call and book an initial consultation to explore the incredible benefits of working with one of the best college planners in the USA. Working with young people and their families all across the USA: (858) 705-0043 (Pacific Time)
Providing answers to your questions about college admissions, financial aid, scholarships, and alternative funding strategies
Total Pageviews
Tuesday, December 18, 2012
Friday, September 14, 2012
Cal State and University of California Schools
The San Diego Union-Tribune recently ran a story that you need to read.
For those of you both in California and across the country who are having difficulty understanding the ramifications of California's budget crisis, this story will hopefully clarify it for you.
Unfortunately, these fine schools are not what they were only a few years ago. Sadly, given the ongoing crisis, no improvement is expected.
http://www.utsandiego.com/news/2012/sep/01/calif-students-face-rocky-path-to-graduation/
Happily the WUE program is proving very helpful to many California students and more students are looking elsewhere. The USA is a big country with a great deal to offer, thankfully!
For those of you both in California and across the country who are having difficulty understanding the ramifications of California's budget crisis, this story will hopefully clarify it for you.
Unfortunately, these fine schools are not what they were only a few years ago. Sadly, given the ongoing crisis, no improvement is expected.
http://www.utsandiego.com/news/2012/sep/01/calif-students-face-rocky-path-to-graduation/
Happily the WUE program is proving very helpful to many California students and more students are looking elsewhere. The USA is a big country with a great deal to offer, thankfully!
Labels:
Berkeley,
Cal State,
californa college students,
California State University,
CSUB,
CSUCI,
SDSU,
SFSU,
SJSU,
SSU,
UCI,
UCLA,
UCR,
UCSB,
UCSD,
University of California,
WUE
Friday, June 29, 2012
Cal Grant Awards to Be Cut
The California budget has been signed and includes several changes to the Cal Grant program. The changes impact Californians attending private and for-profit colleges and universities. However, the proposed increase in qualifying grade point averages was not adopted. The emphasis has been placed, rather, on the ability of the various educational instituions to produce graduates.
The average American takes 6 years to complete a bachelor's degree. The graduation rates cited for colleges are six year rates, unless otherwise noted. In order for colleges to be eligible to award Cal Grants, the colleges must have a six-year graduation rate of at least 30 percent. Additionally they must have a maximum three-year cohort default rate on students loans of 15.5 percent. If the alumni don't repay their loans, their alma mater can lose its ability to award Cal Grants. These new standards apply only to institutions where more than 40 percent of students take out federal loans. Consequently, community colleges are excluded since they are so inexpensive that very few students take federal student loans to attend them.
Beyond the new eligibility rules, the budget imposes across-the-board cuts on maximum Cal Grant awards at private colleges and universities. Students at private, nonprofit colleges will see an immediate 5 percent cut, which will lower the maximum award to $9,223. Further cuts loom, and the Cal Grant for private colleges are set to be limited to $8,056 in 2014. At this time, Cal Grants to public colleges, both the UC and CSU system, as well as the community colleges remain unchanged.
The average American takes 6 years to complete a bachelor's degree. The graduation rates cited for colleges are six year rates, unless otherwise noted. In order for colleges to be eligible to award Cal Grants, the colleges must have a six-year graduation rate of at least 30 percent. Additionally they must have a maximum three-year cohort default rate on students loans of 15.5 percent. If the alumni don't repay their loans, their alma mater can lose its ability to award Cal Grants. These new standards apply only to institutions where more than 40 percent of students take out federal loans. Consequently, community colleges are excluded since they are so inexpensive that very few students take federal student loans to attend them.
Beyond the new eligibility rules, the budget imposes across-the-board cuts on maximum Cal Grant awards at private colleges and universities. Students at private, nonprofit colleges will see an immediate 5 percent cut, which will lower the maximum award to $9,223. Further cuts loom, and the Cal Grant for private colleges are set to be limited to $8,056 in 2014. At this time, Cal Grants to public colleges, both the UC and CSU system, as well as the community colleges remain unchanged.
However, for-profit colleges will again absorb the biggest cuts, with a maximum
Cal Grant award of $4,000 next fall, a significant reduction from the current $9,708. The reason for the lowering of the amount students at for-profit colleges is, reportedly, because of their lower graduation rate.
The new rules will be phased in to minimize the impact on currently
enrolled students. For example, only new students will be prohibited from receiving Cal Grants grants next year at for-profit colleges that
do not meet the requirements. Students currently receiving Cal Grants
will continue to qualify for the award for a year, but will have the
amount reduced by 20 percent.
The new rules are complex, and will impact for-profit colleges in a range of ways.
For example, colleges that receive accreditation from the Western Association of Schools and Colleges (WASC) will be partially exempt from the cuts, said Kent Jenkins, a spokesman for Corinthian Colleges Inc., which owns Heald College.
For detailed information, contact your school or intended school directly.
Read more: http://www.insidehighered.com/news/2012/06/29/profits-take-brunt-new-cal-grant-cuts#ixzz1zD2iDyBT
Inside Higher Ed
For example, colleges that receive accreditation from the Western Association of Schools and Colleges (WASC) will be partially exempt from the cuts, said Kent Jenkins, a spokesman for Corinthian Colleges Inc., which owns Heald College.
For detailed information, contact your school or intended school directly.
Read more: http://www.insidehighered.com/news/2012/06/29/profits-take-brunt-new-cal-grant-cuts#ixzz1zD2iDyBT
Inside Higher Ed
Thursday, June 28, 2012
Campus Visits!
Summer is here and many are headed out to visit some campuses they are seriously considering attending. While the atmosphere on campus is different in the summer, a great deal can still be learned during the summer campus visits. Additionally, families have more time so can explore the campus and surroundings a bit more thoroughly.
When on campus, it is important to strike out, to venture beyond the campus tour. The admissions office has their view of campus life; students have a different perspective. Be sure to register with the admissions office, too.
In order to keep families on track during their visits, and have a place to record their impressions, keep track of contact information as they explore each campus and meet with professors and others, we developed a campus visit guide. It is a reproducible pdf file. Students may make as many copies (one per school is ideal) as needed. Each student will need to buy his or her own copy. Available here.
During and after campus visits, it is essential that notes are taken. Once several campuses have been visited, certain details tend to blend. By taking notes, you'll be sure to remember that Professor Jones was from Northwestern not University of Chicago, for example. Those notes will provide details for application essays, revealing your deep knowledge of the university and your investment in becoming part of their student body.
We found some great tips for you online, too.
When on campus, it is important to strike out, to venture beyond the campus tour. The admissions office has their view of campus life; students have a different perspective. Be sure to register with the admissions office, too.
In order to keep families on track during their visits, and have a place to record their impressions, keep track of contact information as they explore each campus and meet with professors and others, we developed a campus visit guide. It is a reproducible pdf file. Students may make as many copies (one per school is ideal) as needed. Each student will need to buy his or her own copy. Available here.
During and after campus visits, it is essential that notes are taken. Once several campuses have been visited, certain details tend to blend. By taking notes, you'll be sure to remember that Professor Jones was from Northwestern not University of Chicago, for example. Those notes will provide details for application essays, revealing your deep knowledge of the university and your investment in becoming part of their student body.
We found some great tips for you online, too.
U.S. News and World Report: http://www.usnews.com/ education/blogs/twice-the- college-advice/2012/05/22/ plan-college-visits-this- summer
Virtual College Visits (take advantage of the opportunity to visit a college virtually and then in person, when you can): http://www.youvisit.com/ collegesList.php
More college planning tools can be found here: https://celtic.infusionsoft.com/app/storeFront/showCategoryPage?categoryId=1
Tuesday, June 26, 2012
Motivation for Students
Today I'm sharing a column written by a colleague who does wonders helping people work through anxiety - be it the math test or the difficult boss.
Dear Dr. Nikki,
My daughter has begun to lose her motivation for school. Aside from her lack of interest, she finds it difficult to concentrate. Do you have any suggestions for both of these problems?
Motivated Mom
Dear Motivated,
What motivates one person will not necessarily motivate another. One may fear the consequences of not doing well while another may look forward to the rewards they get when they shine. The external prize, such as money or a gift for good grades may light a fire under your daughter or she may seek the internal satisfaction instead. The trick is in finding the key that starts her engine.
There’s a famous radio station with the call letters, WII-FM. These letters stand for ‘what’s in it for me’. There is always something of value in everything we do or we wouldn’t do it. What is the value for her in getting her work done? If there’s no pleasure in the actual work, perhaps she can tell herself the sooner she gets it done, the sooner she can get on to fun things. Help her explore past times when motivation came naturally. If she was swept up in the excitement of the newness, she’ll need to find something she can count on more consistently.
Habits go a long way to helping accomplish things. Chances are she doesn’t need motivation to brush her teeth each day. (Teens' discovery of their attraction to the
opposite sex does have its merits!) The habit puts her on automatic pilot. She does it
without thinking about it and without conscious effort. Try this with homework. Set
aside a particular time of day and teach her to habituate to it. We all have things in life we wish we didn’t have to do. Why are some able to get through the unpleasantness easily while others procrastinate and sink into apathy and become ineffective? Research shows that successful people project into the future and imagine what it will be like when the task is finished. This keeps their enthusiasm going until they can get on to more joyful times. Explain this to your daughter and ask her to try it.
To improve concentration, try this simple trick. Have her play Baroque music softly in the background while she studies. Research shows these compositions create a unique and interesting physiological response in people. It slows the heartbeat to 60 beats per minute and slows the brain waves down too. More of the whole brain is engaged. The result…less distraction and a stronger focus of attention.
Nikki Goldman Ph.D. welcome comments 858-335-9867. Or email DrNikki@DrNikkiGoldman.com She uses hypnotherapy on children and adults to improve self-esteem, study habits, test anxiety and more.
www.DrNikkiGoldman.com
Dear Dr. Nikki,
My daughter has begun to lose her motivation for school. Aside from her lack of interest, she finds it difficult to concentrate. Do you have any suggestions for both of these problems?
Motivated Mom
Dear Motivated,
What motivates one person will not necessarily motivate another. One may fear the consequences of not doing well while another may look forward to the rewards they get when they shine. The external prize, such as money or a gift for good grades may light a fire under your daughter or she may seek the internal satisfaction instead. The trick is in finding the key that starts her engine.
There’s a famous radio station with the call letters, WII-FM. These letters stand for ‘what’s in it for me’. There is always something of value in everything we do or we wouldn’t do it. What is the value for her in getting her work done? If there’s no pleasure in the actual work, perhaps she can tell herself the sooner she gets it done, the sooner she can get on to fun things. Help her explore past times when motivation came naturally. If she was swept up in the excitement of the newness, she’ll need to find something she can count on more consistently.
Habits go a long way to helping accomplish things. Chances are she doesn’t need motivation to brush her teeth each day. (Teens' discovery of their attraction to the
opposite sex does have its merits!) The habit puts her on automatic pilot. She does it
without thinking about it and without conscious effort. Try this with homework. Set
aside a particular time of day and teach her to habituate to it. We all have things in life we wish we didn’t have to do. Why are some able to get through the unpleasantness easily while others procrastinate and sink into apathy and become ineffective? Research shows that successful people project into the future and imagine what it will be like when the task is finished. This keeps their enthusiasm going until they can get on to more joyful times. Explain this to your daughter and ask her to try it.
To improve concentration, try this simple trick. Have her play Baroque music softly in the background while she studies. Research shows these compositions create a unique and interesting physiological response in people. It slows the heartbeat to 60 beats per minute and slows the brain waves down too. More of the whole brain is engaged. The result…less distraction and a stronger focus of attention.
Nikki Goldman Ph.D. welcome comments 858-335-9867. Or email DrNikki@DrNikkiGoldman.com She uses hypnotherapy on children and adults to improve self-esteem, study habits, test anxiety and more.
www.DrNikkiGoldman.com
Tuesday, June 19, 2012
The Value of Starting College Prep Early
Have you noticed the incredible accomplishments of top seniors? Things like four years of
scientific research, athletic achievement, books written and published, music
created and performed, businesses started, the list goes on. It takes intentional
preparation during the junior high/middle school years to be ready to do
those sorts of things in high school. And those high caliber
achievements in high school lead to much higher chances of admissions
and merit scholarships at the colleges right for you.
Does that mean that you have to be super intense at the age of 11 in order to get into college? No, it doesn't. But, if you want to get into elite schools or are already manifesting giftedness in an area, having a coach working with you and your parents will help you develop yourself to be the best you possible. Those gifts are there for a reason. And they need to be encouraged, developed, and shared.
None of us achieves our best alone. It takes the consistent support, encouragement, and guidance of someone who believes in you to draw the best out of each one of us. It takes someone who can look at the possibilities ahead and guide us. Working with a coach means we are not alone, and we can focus on honing our skill while they work with our parents to guide us as we manifest our gifts in our community, whether it be in competitions, charity work, entrepreneurial endeavors, performances, or other venues.
Imagine starting high school with your dream for college firmly in your mind so you are evaluating yourself, identifying strengths (hooray!) and areas which need strengthening. Then, the summer before high school, taking time to improve your time management or organizational skills, or whatever it is you've identified. You walk into high school ready to perform well.
Imagine starting a business between 8th grade and high school. A microbusiness to house sit or tutor or computer servicing or a lawn service company. Rather than just doing a little here and a little there, you take the time to organize and advertise your offering. Now you have something solid to show the admissions committee when you apply for college - and you have likely increased your revenues as well.
Imagine planning your freshman classes with maintaining a 4.0 as your goal, allowing yourself some breathing room in order to adjust to the new environment and expectations that high school brings. Planning your classes to challenge yourself and demonstrate your intellectual giftedness, not overdoing it, and not coasting either.
Starting early also has financial advantages for the family's college fund. Although my services incur costs, the benefits of strategically planning ahead have helped many families lower their college costs as well as significantly increase their college funding resources. Savings of 30% are common ( $40,000+); some families save far more. Let's collaborate!
Click here for more information.
Does that mean that you have to be super intense at the age of 11 in order to get into college? No, it doesn't. But, if you want to get into elite schools or are already manifesting giftedness in an area, having a coach working with you and your parents will help you develop yourself to be the best you possible. Those gifts are there for a reason. And they need to be encouraged, developed, and shared.
None of us achieves our best alone. It takes the consistent support, encouragement, and guidance of someone who believes in you to draw the best out of each one of us. It takes someone who can look at the possibilities ahead and guide us. Working with a coach means we are not alone, and we can focus on honing our skill while they work with our parents to guide us as we manifest our gifts in our community, whether it be in competitions, charity work, entrepreneurial endeavors, performances, or other venues.
Imagine starting high school with your dream for college firmly in your mind so you are evaluating yourself, identifying strengths (hooray!) and areas which need strengthening. Then, the summer before high school, taking time to improve your time management or organizational skills, or whatever it is you've identified. You walk into high school ready to perform well.
Imagine starting a business between 8th grade and high school. A microbusiness to house sit or tutor or computer servicing or a lawn service company. Rather than just doing a little here and a little there, you take the time to organize and advertise your offering. Now you have something solid to show the admissions committee when you apply for college - and you have likely increased your revenues as well.
Imagine planning your freshman classes with maintaining a 4.0 as your goal, allowing yourself some breathing room in order to adjust to the new environment and expectations that high school brings. Planning your classes to challenge yourself and demonstrate your intellectual giftedness, not overdoing it, and not coasting either.
Starting early also has financial advantages for the family's college fund. Although my services incur costs, the benefits of strategically planning ahead have helped many families lower their college costs as well as significantly increase their college funding resources. Savings of 30% are common ( $40,000+); some families save far more. Let's collaborate!
Click here for more information.
Thursday, May 3, 2012
Learning Styles
Your brain uses three primary modes for learning. These modes are the visual, auditory, and kinesthetic. While everyone uses all three modes, one of them is usually dominant and it is very important to identify which one is your primary method for learning.
Visual people tend to think with pictures. They see things they are learning, and analyze the pictures to gain deeper insights and understanding. Visual people also tend to use words that are visual in context like picture, see or image. They also describe things using visual metaphors like bright or colored. If you identify with this description than you are probably a visual learner.
Auditory people tend to think by listening to their inner voice. They think about things using words and phrases, and analyze what they hear to make their decisions. They often say things like, "are you listening", or "did you hear what I just told you." They also describe things using auditory metaphors like loud and melodic. If you identify with this description than you are probably an auditory learner.
Kinesthetic people tend to think base on their feelings. They need time to connect with ideas at a gut level and tend to use terms like, "how does this feel to you", or "are you comfortable with what I am telling you." They also describe things using kinesthetic metaphors like comfortable or pleasant. If you identify with this description than you are probably a kinesthetic learner.
The Importance of Repetition
Regardless of which mode your brain primarily uses to process information, repetition also plays an important role in learning. Did you know that information must be repeated from 1-20 times before it finally sticks into memory? Too many individuals rely upon a single pass through a text to lock in critical information. It is little wonder their success doesn't reflect the amount of time they've invested in learning. Remember repetition is an important part of learning...repetition is an important part of learning.
It takes time before your brain can validate information as significant enough to retain. Your brain's main purpose is to find or create patterns that will prove useful to your success and survival.
Moving From Facts to Understanding
Facts may prove useful on some tests, but don't truly measure your understanding. Understanding a pattern provides the brain with its true significance. The limbic system or emotional brain also plays a role in moving from facts to understanding. It is important that something feel significant or important so your brain will feel compelled to retain the information for later use.
You can get more learning strategies and powerful programs at www.HowToLearnAnythingFaster.com
Howard Stephen Berg Learning Systems LLC
5100 Eldorado Parkway
Suite 102-720
McKinney, TX
75070
US
Visual people tend to think with pictures. They see things they are learning, and analyze the pictures to gain deeper insights and understanding. Visual people also tend to use words that are visual in context like picture, see or image. They also describe things using visual metaphors like bright or colored. If you identify with this description than you are probably a visual learner.
Auditory people tend to think by listening to their inner voice. They think about things using words and phrases, and analyze what they hear to make their decisions. They often say things like, "are you listening", or "did you hear what I just told you." They also describe things using auditory metaphors like loud and melodic. If you identify with this description than you are probably an auditory learner.
Kinesthetic people tend to think base on their feelings. They need time to connect with ideas at a gut level and tend to use terms like, "how does this feel to you", or "are you comfortable with what I am telling you." They also describe things using kinesthetic metaphors like comfortable or pleasant. If you identify with this description than you are probably a kinesthetic learner.
The Importance of Repetition
Regardless of which mode your brain primarily uses to process information, repetition also plays an important role in learning. Did you know that information must be repeated from 1-20 times before it finally sticks into memory? Too many individuals rely upon a single pass through a text to lock in critical information. It is little wonder their success doesn't reflect the amount of time they've invested in learning. Remember repetition is an important part of learning...repetition is an important part of learning.
It takes time before your brain can validate information as significant enough to retain. Your brain's main purpose is to find or create patterns that will prove useful to your success and survival.
Moving From Facts to Understanding
Facts may prove useful on some tests, but don't truly measure your understanding. Understanding a pattern provides the brain with its true significance. The limbic system or emotional brain also plays a role in moving from facts to understanding. It is important that something feel significant or important so your brain will feel compelled to retain the information for later use.
You can get more learning strategies and powerful programs at www.HowToLearnAnythingFaster.com
Howard Stephen Berg Learning Systems LLC
5100 Eldorado Parkway
Suite 102-720
McKinney, TX
75070
US
Tuesday, May 1, 2012
From HSLDA:
(Home School Legal Defense Association)
Home schooled students ARE eligible for financial aid!
Scott Woodruff answers questions and assists members with legal issues in Idaho. He and his wife homeschooled their children. Read more >>
Last week the Idaho State Board of Education (ISBE) adopted a new
rule that should quell the recent controversy about whether
homeschoolers need a GED for college admission. Effective immediately,
all Idaho public colleges should cease asking homeschoolers for a GED
because of the new rule, Idaho Administrative Code 08.02.03.118.
Several years ago, some colleges refused to believe that homeschoolers were eligible for federal financial aid (and colleges don’t want to admit students who are not eligible). They asserted that a homeschool student could only qualify by obtaining a GED or by the “back door” route of getting an adequate score on a standardized test to prove he had the “ability to benefit” from a college education. These colleges refused to acknowledge that a graduate of a homeschool program was eligible for federal financial aid in his own right.
HSLDA asked Congress to pass a new law to protect homeschoolers. But we were concerned that if the law only referred to “homeschoolers,” it would not protect families in the many states where a homeschool is a private school. For example, in Kansas, Illinois, Indiana, Texas and others, state law acknowledges private schools, but nothing called a “homeschool”—even though that’s what they are called in everyday conversation.
So the law Congress passed to cover homeschoolers in all states referred to “a home school setting that is treated as a home school or private school under State law.” (20 U.S.C. §1091(d)) Problems with college admissions virtually disappeared.
But two surprises popped up. First, we learned that a number of colleges—in defiance of federal law—were treating homeschoolers as if they had to prove their ability to benefit. And second, an influential organization erroneously told college admissions officials that if their state’s law did not use the precise phrase “home school,” a homeschooler would not be eligible as a homeschooler.
This was obviously preposterous. Congress used the term “homeschool” because it is quite well understood in common usage, no matter what nuance of language is used in each state’s law.
In Iowa, homeschooling is technically known as “competent private instruction.” In South Dakota, it’s “alternative instruction.” In Virginia, it’s “home instruction.” And so on. But it’s all homeschooling, as Congress understood very well.
But admissions officers—fearful that they might be personally on the hook for any mistake—grabbed the erroneous guidance and treated it like gospel. Regrettably, the herd instinct took over.
Soon many admissions officials were afraid to admit homeschoolers if their state’s law did not use that exact term “home school”! HSLDA immediately went to work to solve the problem at the national level, and collaborated closely with Idaho Coalition of Home Educators (ICHE) on the state level.
Some Idaho colleges had drafted revised favorable new homeschool policies in anticipation of the new state rule. We now expect them to quickly pivot and apply the new rule. However, students whose college admissions have been in limbo should contact the relevant admissions official to make sure they are following the new rule.
The new rule is not yet readily accessible on the internet. If you encounter a still-confused admissions official, promptly contact us with their name and phone number, and we will follow up.
Our thanks go to ICHE for their excellent work on this issue.
(Home School Legal Defense Association)
Home schooled students ARE eligible for financial aid!
New Rule Ends College Admission Controversy
Scott Woodruff answers questions and assists members with legal issues in Idaho. He and his wife homeschooled their children. Read more >>
Refusing Aid
Here’s some background on how the problem arose in the first place.Several years ago, some colleges refused to believe that homeschoolers were eligible for federal financial aid (and colleges don’t want to admit students who are not eligible). They asserted that a homeschool student could only qualify by obtaining a GED or by the “back door” route of getting an adequate score on a standardized test to prove he had the “ability to benefit” from a college education. These colleges refused to acknowledge that a graduate of a homeschool program was eligible for federal financial aid in his own right.
HSLDA asked Congress to pass a new law to protect homeschoolers. But we were concerned that if the law only referred to “homeschoolers,” it would not protect families in the many states where a homeschool is a private school. For example, in Kansas, Illinois, Indiana, Texas and others, state law acknowledges private schools, but nothing called a “homeschool”—even though that’s what they are called in everyday conversation.
So the law Congress passed to cover homeschoolers in all states referred to “a home school setting that is treated as a home school or private school under State law.” (20 U.S.C. §1091(d)) Problems with college admissions virtually disappeared.
Problems Arise
Then last year Congress repealed the “back door” option for qualifying for financial aid as part of its effort to quash diploma mills. Homeschoolers should not have been affected, since a homeschool graduate is eligible without proving his ability to benefit from a college education.But two surprises popped up. First, we learned that a number of colleges—in defiance of federal law—were treating homeschoolers as if they had to prove their ability to benefit. And second, an influential organization erroneously told college admissions officials that if their state’s law did not use the precise phrase “home school,” a homeschooler would not be eligible as a homeschooler.
This was obviously preposterous. Congress used the term “homeschool” because it is quite well understood in common usage, no matter what nuance of language is used in each state’s law.
In Iowa, homeschooling is technically known as “competent private instruction.” In South Dakota, it’s “alternative instruction.” In Virginia, it’s “home instruction.” And so on. But it’s all homeschooling, as Congress understood very well.
But admissions officers—fearful that they might be personally on the hook for any mistake—grabbed the erroneous guidance and treated it like gospel. Regrettably, the herd instinct took over.
Soon many admissions officials were afraid to admit homeschoolers if their state’s law did not use that exact term “home school”! HSLDA immediately went to work to solve the problem at the national level, and collaborated closely with Idaho Coalition of Home Educators (ICHE) on the state level.
Clearing up the Language
The ISBE’s new rule solves Idaho’s problem by connecting the phrase “home school” to the Idaho statute under which families educate their children. There can no longer be any doubt—if there ever was a plausible reason to doubt—that what we have called “homeschooling” for decades in Idaho is truly “home schooling!”Some Idaho colleges had drafted revised favorable new homeschool policies in anticipation of the new state rule. We now expect them to quickly pivot and apply the new rule. However, students whose college admissions have been in limbo should contact the relevant admissions official to make sure they are following the new rule.
The new rule is not yet readily accessible on the internet. If you encounter a still-confused admissions official, promptly contact us with their name and phone number, and we will follow up.
Our thanks go to ICHE for their excellent work on this issue.
Friday, April 20, 2012
Acceptable Documentation for Verification - Data Retrieval Tool Failure
In the limited set of cases where an aid applicant, who has filed a tax return and attempted unsuccessfully to use the IRS Data Retrieval Tool or to obtain IRS Tax Return transcripts, needs a timely alternative for meeting the 2012-13 verification requirements, institutions may, until July 15, 2012, use a signed copy of the relevant (i.e., applicant, spouse, or parent) 2011 IRS Tax Return (Form 1040, 1040A, or 1040EZ, as appropriate) as acceptable verification documentation for the 2012-13 award year.From NASFAA
Thursday, April 12, 2012
IRS Newswire
April 11, 2012
Issue Number: IR-2012-46
Inside This Issue
Last-Minute Reminder to Parents and Students; Don’t Overlook College Tax Benefits
IRS YouTube Videos:
Education Tax Credits and Deductions: English
Education Tax Credit - Claim It - Parents: English | Spanish | ASL
Education Tax Credit - Claim It - Students: English | ASL
Podcast: Education Tax Credits and Deductions
WASHINGTON — The Internal Revenue Service today reminded parents and students rushing to meet this year’s April 17 deadline to be sure and check out several college-related tax benefits before filing their 2011 returns.
Two tax credits and a tax deduction are available to taxpayers who paid tuition and other expenses for an eligible student during 2011. Because an eligible student can be the taxpayer, spouse or dependent, these benefits can, for example, help workers taking continuing education courses and people returning to school, as well as parents paying for their children’s college education.
Given the number of different higher education credits and deductions, the IRS reminds taxpayers to carefully review eligibility requirements so they don’t overlook these important college benefits. Tax benefits include the following:
The American Opportunity Tax Credit helps pay for the first four years of post-secondary education. Tuition, required enrollment fees, books and other required course materials generally qualify, and eligible students must be enrolled at least half time. Qualifying expenses of $4,000 or more in 2011 can earn a taxpayer the maximum credit of $2,500 per student per year. Even taxpayers who owe no tax can get a payment of the credit of up to $1,000 for each eligible student. The credit is claimed on Form 8863. But the IRS warns taxpayers to avoid an often-costly tax scam, currently being promoted widely to senior citizens, low-income families and church members falsely claiming that refunds based on the credit are available, even if they’re not currently enrolled in college and even if they went to school decades ago. In addition, some international students, normally considered nonresident aliens for tax purposes, have been improperly advised that they qualify for the credit.
The Lifetime Learning Credit, limited to $2,000 per taxpayer per year, can be claimed based on tuition and required enrollment fees paid for any level of post-secondary education. Because of differences between the two credits and the fact that the American Opportunity Tax Credit usually yields greater tax savings at the undergraduate level, the Lifetime Learning Credit may be particularly helpful to graduate students, students taking only one course and those who are not pursuing a degree. The Lifetime Learning Credit is also claimed on Form 8863.
The tuition and fees deduction is available for both full-time and part-time students at all levels of post-secondary education. The deduction of up to $4,000 is claimed on Form 8917.
Each year, a student normally receives a Form 1098-T from their college showing tuition payments and other information.
Though a taxpayer often qualifies for more than one of these benefits, he or she can only claim one of them for a particular student in 2011. Income limits and other special rules apply to each of these benefits. The general comparison table in Publication 970 can be a useful guide to taxpayers in determining eligibility for each of these benefits.
Often, tax credits are more valuable, because they reduce the amount of tax owed, whereas deductions reduce the income on which tax is figured. Tax software can often help parents and students determine which benefit yields the greatest tax savings.
Besides these tax benefits, parents, students and former students who made student loan payments during 2011 can deduct up to $2,500 of student loan interest. Normally, borrowers receive from their financial institution Form 1098-E showing student loan interest paid for the year. This deduction is claimed on Form 1040 Line 33 or Form 1040A Line 18. Income limits and other special rules apply. For example, the student must have been enrolled at least half time in a degree or certificate program. A worksheet in the tax form instructions can help taxpayers figure the deduction correctly.
The student loan interest deduction, the tuition and fees deduction and both tax credits can be claimed by eligible taxpayers, regardless of whether they itemize deductions on Schedule A. These benefits are available to both Form 1040 and 1040A filers. Details on these and other education-related deductions and credits can be found in the Tax Benefits for Education Information Center on IRS.gov.
Thank you for subscribing to the IRS Newswire, an IRS e-mail service.
Friday, March 30, 2012
Graduate School is a Means to a Job
This article is excellent. In order to ensure its availability to my readers, I am posting it here in full, including the byline.
Enlarge Image
Excellent question. As a graduate student, your fate is in your own hands, and every decision you make—including whether to go to graduate school at all, which program to go to, which adviser to choose, and how to conduct yourself while there—can and should be made with an eye to the job you wish to have at the end.
To do otherwise is pure madness. I have no patience whatsoever with the "love" narrative (we do what we do because we love it and money/jobs play no role) that prevails among some advisers, departments, and profoundly mystified graduate students. But for those graduate students and Ph.D.'s who actually want a paying tenure-track job and the things that go with it—health insurance, benefits, and financial security—here is my list of graduate-school rules, forged after years of working in academe as a former tenured professor and now running my own career-advising business for doctoral students.
Before Graduate School
Ask yourself what job you want and whether an advanced degree is actually necessary for it.
Choose your graduate program based both on its focus on your scholarly interests and its tenure-track placement rate. If it doesn't keep careful records of its placement rate, or does not have an impressive record of placing its Ph.D.'s in tenure-track positions, do not consider attending that program.
Choose your adviser the same way. Before committing to an adviser, find out how many Ph.D.'s that potential mentor has placed in tenure-track positions in recent years.
Go to the highest-ranked graduate department you can get into—so long as it funds you fully. That is not actually because of the "snob factor" of the name itself, but rather because of the ethos of the best departments. They typically are the best financed, which means they have more scholars with national reputations to serve as your mentors and letter writers, and they maintain lively brown-bag and seminar series that bring in major visiting scholars with whom you can network. The placement history of a top program tends to produce its own momentum, so that departments around the country with faculty members from that program will then look kindly on new applications from its latest Ph.D.'s. That, my friends, is how privilege reproduces itself. It may be distasteful, but you deny or ignore it at your peril.
Never assume that the elite, Ivy League departments are the highest-ranked or have the best placement rates. Some of the worst-prepared job candidates with whom I've worked have been from humanities departments at Yale, Harvard, and Princeton. Do not be dazzled by abstract institutional reputations. Ask steely-eyed questions about individual advisers and their actual (not illusory) placement rates in recent years.
Meet, or at least correspond, with your potential adviser ahead of time so that you understand whether he or she has a hands-on approach to professionalization training and will be personally invested in your success.
Do not attend graduate school unless you are fully supported by—at minimum—a multiyear teaching assistantship that provides a tuition waiver, a stipend, and health insurance that covers most of the years of your program. The stipend needs to be generous enough to support your actual living expenses for the location. Do not take out new debt to attend graduate school. Because the tenure-track job market is so bleak, graduate school in the humanities and social sciences is, in most cases, not worth going into debt for.
Apply to 6 to 10 graduate programs. If you are admitted with funding to more than one, negotiate to get the best possible package at your top choice.
Be entrepreneurial before even entering graduate school to locate and apply for multiple sources of financial support. Do not forget the law of increasing returns: Success breeds success and large follows small. A $500 book scholarship makes you more competitive for a $1,000 conference grant, which situates you for a $3,000 summer-research fellowship, which puts you in the running for a $10,000 fieldwork grant, which then makes you competitive for a $30,000 dissertation writing grant.
Early in Graduate School
Never forget this primary rule: Graduate school is not your job; graduate school is a means to the job you want. Do not settle in to your graduate department like a little hamster burrowing in the wood shavings. Stay alert with your eye always on a national stage, poised for the next opportunity, whatever it is: to present a paper, attend a conference, meet a scholar in your field, forge a connection, gain a professional skill.
In year one and every year thereafter, read the job ads in your field, and track the predominant and emerging emphases of the listed jobs. Ask yourself how you can incorporate those into your own project, directly or indirectly. You don't have to slavishly follow trends, but you have to be familiar with them and be prepared to relate your own work to them in some way.
Have a beautifully organized and professional CV starting in your first year and in every subsequent year. When I was a young assistant professor, a senior colleague told me that her philosophy was to add one line a month to her CV. Set that same goal for yourself. As a junior graduate student, you may or may not be able to maintain that pace, but keep it in the back of your mind, and keep your eye out for opportunities that add lines to your CV at a brisk pace.
Make strong connections with your adviser and other faculty members in your department, and in affiliated departments. Interact with them as a young professional, respectfully but confidently. Eschew excessive humility; it inspires contempt. Do not forget the letters of recommendation that you will one day need them to write.
Minimize your work as a TA. Your first year will be grueling, but learn the efficiency techniques of teaching as fast as you can, and make absolutely, categorically, sure that you do not volunteer your labor beyond the hours paid. Believe me, resisting will take vigilance. But do it. You are not a volunteer and the university is not a charity. You are paid for hours of work; do not exceed them. Teach well, but do not make teaching the core of your identity.
Be aware that faculty members in a variety of departments will be able to direct you to different grant sources, which, over time, will help you to continue paying for your studies without accruing crushing debt. Not all faculty members are familiar with the same grant sources, so breadth is important.
Strategize your writing projects in your courses, theses, and dissertation, to form the basis of potentially publishable papers. If offered the option of writing a master's thesis, seriously consider taking it, as it can form the core of your first refereed journal article. Plan out a publishing trajectory to ensure that you have at least one sole-authored refereed journal article before you defend your dissertation.
Attend every job talk in your department and affiliated departments religiously. It matters not if those talks are in your field or subfield. Go to them all. Job talks and other job-search opportunities such as attending a lunch with a candidate, serving on a search committee, or simply examining an applicant's CV and file are the single best training you can provide yourself on the real requirements of the tenure-track job market (as opposed to your private and often delusional perceptions).
Attend national conferences annually. It's fine to also go to local and regional conferences, but they must never take the place of your national conference, which provides irreplaceable insight into trends in your field, the ethos and habitus of your discipline, and the behavioral norms of professional scholars. It also presents the opportunity to network and to attend seminars dedicated to professional skills such as writing grant proposals or journal articles.
Strategize how to travel to conferences, and work with your cohort to make it a habit of driving together to major national conferences, and lodging together.
Apply indiscriminately for money, and master the fine art of tailoring to meet the grant agency's mission. You'll be surprised by how much the act of transforming your project to meet a new mission reveals to you hitherto unrecognized potentialities and insights into the work itself. Applying for a wide range of grants is one of the best intellectual exercises in which you can engage.
Take every opportunity available to present your work publicly. While I emphasized the importance of national conferences for reputation purposes, actively pursue every possible local and regional opportunity for experience purposes. Public speaking is one of the core skills of an academic career. Make your mistakes in graduate school, where the stakes are low, so that you are a master of the podium when the stakes are high.
In Your Final Years of Graduate School
Avoid like the plague offers of publication in edited collections, which is where good publications go to die. If you have a piece of work that can pass muster as a publication, make sure that it goes into a refereed journal, the best one you can reasonably manage. Don't ever throw it away on conference proceedings, or the like. (That applies to the humanities and most social sciences; some conference proceedings in the sciences are legitimate publication venues. Know your field.) So do not be seduced by expressions of interest from editors of collections or third-tier journals following your conference presentations. The opportunity may seem easy but you will pay the price later when the collection is delayed for years or the publication is deemed too low status to help you on the market.
By your third year or so, apply annually to present a paper at your national conference. If you are in the humanities, do not waste time participating in poster sessions. If you are in the hard sciences or experimental social sciences, check with a trusted adviser about the value of posters. Near the end of your program, begin to organize panels for a conference. Your first foray in that direction can be with other graduate students, but don't organize more than one graduate-student panel in your career.
In the year before you go on the job market, organize and propose a high-profile panel for your national conference that is made up of young, up-and-coming assistant professors. Ask a well-known scholar to serve as discussant. Make efforts to have the panel respond to, or engage with, a trending topic in your field and/or one that is identified as the primary theme of that year's national meetings. This panel is your "coming out" party, and makes you visible on a national stage, framed and contextualized by the more senior scholars who already have reputations on the panel's topic. At the conference, do not forget to organize a lunch (or dinner or coffee) for the panelists to get to know them better and lay the groundwork for future collaborations and possibly letters of recommendation.
Cultivate a letter writer who is not from your Ph.D.-granting institution. Having all your recommendation letters come from your own committee or department is the sign of a relatively immature candidate. It is not a death knell in your first or second years on the market, but be aware that the strongest and most successful candidates will have a recommendation from an influential senior scholar from outside their home department who can speak to their standing in the field (and not simply to their performance as a graduate student in the department).
Write your dissertation with an eye to the publications that it will become. Be aware that in most fields, at least one refereed journal article while you are still A.B.D. is now necessary to get shortlisted for tenure-track jobs. At the same time, be aware that publications that date from before you accept your tenure-track job sometimes do not count toward tenure. So the balance is delicate indeed. You must publish enough to get a job without prematurely exhausting your supply of material you will need for tenure. (That is why I recommend writing a master's thesis, which will give you material for a publication without cutting into your dissertation material.)
If you are in a book field, be aware that presses will not look kindly at a book proposal in which more than half of the material has already been published in articles. Therefore, in a typical five-chapter dissertation, you want no more than two chapters to be put out as refereed journal articles. While writing the dissertation, have a publishing plan in place. You may write one chapter, for example, with an eye to fast publication while you are A.B.D. Set aside other material for refereed journal articles while you're on the tenure track. Meanwhile, write the dissertation itself as much like a book as your committee will allow. If your committee insists on methodology and theory chapters, write them with the full knowledge that they will most likely be removed from the ultimate book manuscript.
Remember that the best dissertation is a finished dissertation. Your dissertation must satisfy a committee, while your book must satisfy a set of reviewers and an editor who operate nationally and internationally. Do what it takes to satisfy your committee and finish. Leave the Sturm und Drang for when you are revising the manuscript into the book that will become the real mark of your scholarly reputation.
Be the sole instructor of at least one course but not more than three (if you can help it). After about three, the benefit of additional teaching experience diminishes, and becomes a distraction from the real capital-producing work necessary for the tenure-track job market, which (unless you're applying to community colleges) is publication and conference activity. If your department does not offer A.B.D.'s the opportunity to teach your own courses, then carefully seek an opportunity from another college in the area. Do a good job, but do not allow your teaching to derail you from the writing, publishing, grant writing, and conferences that are the core elements of the tenure-track search. TA experience is not an adequate substitute for teaching a course of your own.
Go on the market while A.B.D. because you want to make your worst mistakes while you still have a year of financial support from your home department. Most people who prevail on the market need at least two years to do so.
Cultivate a professional persona as a young scholar. That persona is separate from your previous identity as a graduate student and is, instead, confident, assertive, sophisticated, and outspoken. Devote as much time as it takes to writing out brief—and I do mean brief—summaries of your dissertation research, teaching techniques and philosophy, and your future publication plans. Practice delivering those brief summaries until they become second nature.
Make your application materials absolutely flawless. Take your ego out of the process and ask everyone you know to ruthlessly critique your CV, letter, teaching statement, and research statement. Prioritize the advice you receive from young faculty members who have recently been on the market, and from senior professors who have recently chaired a search committee.
Some graduate students will rush to follow these rules, some will panic and view the task as impossible, and others will indignantly deny the validity of these steps. The choice is entirely yours. But be aware that the best and most competitive candidates—the ones whom I have watched and assisted as they sailed through the job market—had every one of these elements of their record locked and loaded.
March 27, 2012
Graduate School Is a Means to a Job
Brian Taylor for The Chronicle
By Karen Kelsky
One of the most common questions I hear from graduate
students, whether they are in their first or their final year, is what
they can do now to prepare for the academic job market.Excellent question. As a graduate student, your fate is in your own hands, and every decision you make—including whether to go to graduate school at all, which program to go to, which adviser to choose, and how to conduct yourself while there—can and should be made with an eye to the job you wish to have at the end.
To do otherwise is pure madness. I have no patience whatsoever with the "love" narrative (we do what we do because we love it and money/jobs play no role) that prevails among some advisers, departments, and profoundly mystified graduate students. But for those graduate students and Ph.D.'s who actually want a paying tenure-track job and the things that go with it—health insurance, benefits, and financial security—here is my list of graduate-school rules, forged after years of working in academe as a former tenured professor and now running my own career-advising business for doctoral students.
Before Graduate School
Ask yourself what job you want and whether an advanced degree is actually necessary for it.
Choose your graduate program based both on its focus on your scholarly interests and its tenure-track placement rate. If it doesn't keep careful records of its placement rate, or does not have an impressive record of placing its Ph.D.'s in tenure-track positions, do not consider attending that program.
Choose your adviser the same way. Before committing to an adviser, find out how many Ph.D.'s that potential mentor has placed in tenure-track positions in recent years.
Go to the highest-ranked graduate department you can get into—so long as it funds you fully. That is not actually because of the "snob factor" of the name itself, but rather because of the ethos of the best departments. They typically are the best financed, which means they have more scholars with national reputations to serve as your mentors and letter writers, and they maintain lively brown-bag and seminar series that bring in major visiting scholars with whom you can network. The placement history of a top program tends to produce its own momentum, so that departments around the country with faculty members from that program will then look kindly on new applications from its latest Ph.D.'s. That, my friends, is how privilege reproduces itself. It may be distasteful, but you deny or ignore it at your peril.
Never assume that the elite, Ivy League departments are the highest-ranked or have the best placement rates. Some of the worst-prepared job candidates with whom I've worked have been from humanities departments at Yale, Harvard, and Princeton. Do not be dazzled by abstract institutional reputations. Ask steely-eyed questions about individual advisers and their actual (not illusory) placement rates in recent years.
Meet, or at least correspond, with your potential adviser ahead of time so that you understand whether he or she has a hands-on approach to professionalization training and will be personally invested in your success.
Do not attend graduate school unless you are fully supported by—at minimum—a multiyear teaching assistantship that provides a tuition waiver, a stipend, and health insurance that covers most of the years of your program. The stipend needs to be generous enough to support your actual living expenses for the location. Do not take out new debt to attend graduate school. Because the tenure-track job market is so bleak, graduate school in the humanities and social sciences is, in most cases, not worth going into debt for.
Apply to 6 to 10 graduate programs. If you are admitted with funding to more than one, negotiate to get the best possible package at your top choice.
Be entrepreneurial before even entering graduate school to locate and apply for multiple sources of financial support. Do not forget the law of increasing returns: Success breeds success and large follows small. A $500 book scholarship makes you more competitive for a $1,000 conference grant, which situates you for a $3,000 summer-research fellowship, which puts you in the running for a $10,000 fieldwork grant, which then makes you competitive for a $30,000 dissertation writing grant.
Early in Graduate School
Never forget this primary rule: Graduate school is not your job; graduate school is a means to the job you want. Do not settle in to your graduate department like a little hamster burrowing in the wood shavings. Stay alert with your eye always on a national stage, poised for the next opportunity, whatever it is: to present a paper, attend a conference, meet a scholar in your field, forge a connection, gain a professional skill.
In year one and every year thereafter, read the job ads in your field, and track the predominant and emerging emphases of the listed jobs. Ask yourself how you can incorporate those into your own project, directly or indirectly. You don't have to slavishly follow trends, but you have to be familiar with them and be prepared to relate your own work to them in some way.
Have a beautifully organized and professional CV starting in your first year and in every subsequent year. When I was a young assistant professor, a senior colleague told me that her philosophy was to add one line a month to her CV. Set that same goal for yourself. As a junior graduate student, you may or may not be able to maintain that pace, but keep it in the back of your mind, and keep your eye out for opportunities that add lines to your CV at a brisk pace.
Make strong connections with your adviser and other faculty members in your department, and in affiliated departments. Interact with them as a young professional, respectfully but confidently. Eschew excessive humility; it inspires contempt. Do not forget the letters of recommendation that you will one day need them to write.
Minimize your work as a TA. Your first year will be grueling, but learn the efficiency techniques of teaching as fast as you can, and make absolutely, categorically, sure that you do not volunteer your labor beyond the hours paid. Believe me, resisting will take vigilance. But do it. You are not a volunteer and the university is not a charity. You are paid for hours of work; do not exceed them. Teach well, but do not make teaching the core of your identity.
Be aware that faculty members in a variety of departments will be able to direct you to different grant sources, which, over time, will help you to continue paying for your studies without accruing crushing debt. Not all faculty members are familiar with the same grant sources, so breadth is important.
Strategize your writing projects in your courses, theses, and dissertation, to form the basis of potentially publishable papers. If offered the option of writing a master's thesis, seriously consider taking it, as it can form the core of your first refereed journal article. Plan out a publishing trajectory to ensure that you have at least one sole-authored refereed journal article before you defend your dissertation.
Attend every job talk in your department and affiliated departments religiously. It matters not if those talks are in your field or subfield. Go to them all. Job talks and other job-search opportunities such as attending a lunch with a candidate, serving on a search committee, or simply examining an applicant's CV and file are the single best training you can provide yourself on the real requirements of the tenure-track job market (as opposed to your private and often delusional perceptions).
Attend national conferences annually. It's fine to also go to local and regional conferences, but they must never take the place of your national conference, which provides irreplaceable insight into trends in your field, the ethos and habitus of your discipline, and the behavioral norms of professional scholars. It also presents the opportunity to network and to attend seminars dedicated to professional skills such as writing grant proposals or journal articles.
Strategize how to travel to conferences, and work with your cohort to make it a habit of driving together to major national conferences, and lodging together.
Apply indiscriminately for money, and master the fine art of tailoring to meet the grant agency's mission. You'll be surprised by how much the act of transforming your project to meet a new mission reveals to you hitherto unrecognized potentialities and insights into the work itself. Applying for a wide range of grants is one of the best intellectual exercises in which you can engage.
Take every opportunity available to present your work publicly. While I emphasized the importance of national conferences for reputation purposes, actively pursue every possible local and regional opportunity for experience purposes. Public speaking is one of the core skills of an academic career. Make your mistakes in graduate school, where the stakes are low, so that you are a master of the podium when the stakes are high.
In Your Final Years of Graduate School
Avoid like the plague offers of publication in edited collections, which is where good publications go to die. If you have a piece of work that can pass muster as a publication, make sure that it goes into a refereed journal, the best one you can reasonably manage. Don't ever throw it away on conference proceedings, or the like. (That applies to the humanities and most social sciences; some conference proceedings in the sciences are legitimate publication venues. Know your field.) So do not be seduced by expressions of interest from editors of collections or third-tier journals following your conference presentations. The opportunity may seem easy but you will pay the price later when the collection is delayed for years or the publication is deemed too low status to help you on the market.
By your third year or so, apply annually to present a paper at your national conference. If you are in the humanities, do not waste time participating in poster sessions. If you are in the hard sciences or experimental social sciences, check with a trusted adviser about the value of posters. Near the end of your program, begin to organize panels for a conference. Your first foray in that direction can be with other graduate students, but don't organize more than one graduate-student panel in your career.
In the year before you go on the job market, organize and propose a high-profile panel for your national conference that is made up of young, up-and-coming assistant professors. Ask a well-known scholar to serve as discussant. Make efforts to have the panel respond to, or engage with, a trending topic in your field and/or one that is identified as the primary theme of that year's national meetings. This panel is your "coming out" party, and makes you visible on a national stage, framed and contextualized by the more senior scholars who already have reputations on the panel's topic. At the conference, do not forget to organize a lunch (or dinner or coffee) for the panelists to get to know them better and lay the groundwork for future collaborations and possibly letters of recommendation.
Cultivate a letter writer who is not from your Ph.D.-granting institution. Having all your recommendation letters come from your own committee or department is the sign of a relatively immature candidate. It is not a death knell in your first or second years on the market, but be aware that the strongest and most successful candidates will have a recommendation from an influential senior scholar from outside their home department who can speak to their standing in the field (and not simply to their performance as a graduate student in the department).
Write your dissertation with an eye to the publications that it will become. Be aware that in most fields, at least one refereed journal article while you are still A.B.D. is now necessary to get shortlisted for tenure-track jobs. At the same time, be aware that publications that date from before you accept your tenure-track job sometimes do not count toward tenure. So the balance is delicate indeed. You must publish enough to get a job without prematurely exhausting your supply of material you will need for tenure. (That is why I recommend writing a master's thesis, which will give you material for a publication without cutting into your dissertation material.)
If you are in a book field, be aware that presses will not look kindly at a book proposal in which more than half of the material has already been published in articles. Therefore, in a typical five-chapter dissertation, you want no more than two chapters to be put out as refereed journal articles. While writing the dissertation, have a publishing plan in place. You may write one chapter, for example, with an eye to fast publication while you are A.B.D. Set aside other material for refereed journal articles while you're on the tenure track. Meanwhile, write the dissertation itself as much like a book as your committee will allow. If your committee insists on methodology and theory chapters, write them with the full knowledge that they will most likely be removed from the ultimate book manuscript.
Remember that the best dissertation is a finished dissertation. Your dissertation must satisfy a committee, while your book must satisfy a set of reviewers and an editor who operate nationally and internationally. Do what it takes to satisfy your committee and finish. Leave the Sturm und Drang for when you are revising the manuscript into the book that will become the real mark of your scholarly reputation.
Be the sole instructor of at least one course but not more than three (if you can help it). After about three, the benefit of additional teaching experience diminishes, and becomes a distraction from the real capital-producing work necessary for the tenure-track job market, which (unless you're applying to community colleges) is publication and conference activity. If your department does not offer A.B.D.'s the opportunity to teach your own courses, then carefully seek an opportunity from another college in the area. Do a good job, but do not allow your teaching to derail you from the writing, publishing, grant writing, and conferences that are the core elements of the tenure-track search. TA experience is not an adequate substitute for teaching a course of your own.
Go on the market while A.B.D. because you want to make your worst mistakes while you still have a year of financial support from your home department. Most people who prevail on the market need at least two years to do so.
Cultivate a professional persona as a young scholar. That persona is separate from your previous identity as a graduate student and is, instead, confident, assertive, sophisticated, and outspoken. Devote as much time as it takes to writing out brief—and I do mean brief—summaries of your dissertation research, teaching techniques and philosophy, and your future publication plans. Practice delivering those brief summaries until they become second nature.
Make your application materials absolutely flawless. Take your ego out of the process and ask everyone you know to ruthlessly critique your CV, letter, teaching statement, and research statement. Prioritize the advice you receive from young faculty members who have recently been on the market, and from senior professors who have recently chaired a search committee.
Some graduate students will rush to follow these rules, some will panic and view the task as impossible, and others will indignantly deny the validity of these steps. The choice is entirely yours. But be aware that the best and most competitive candidates—the ones whom I have watched and assisted as they sailed through the job market—had every one of these elements of their record locked and loaded.
Karen Kelsky is a former professor of
anthropology at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign and the
University of Oregon who left academe in 2010. She now runs a consulting
business and a blog called The Professor Is In.
Tuesday, March 20, 2012
Which School is Cheaper?
The posted prices of the schools are often not what a given family actually pays for a student to attend that university. Scholarships and grants and tuition reductions change that figure.
Here is an example which shows clearly that you can't really decide a school is too expensive by looking at its listed costs.
On Harvard's website, the net
calculator shows that a family of four with a $130,000 annual income could
qualify for as much as a $39,750 scholarship for the undergrad program. That reduces the $56,750 for freshman tuition, room and board at Harvard to $17,000.
At California State University in Los Angeles, the cost of tuition, room board and other fees is a mere $21,335 per year. However, that same family of four making $130,000 wouldn't qualify for any aid, according to their calculator.
At California State University in Los Angeles, the cost of tuition, room board and other fees is a mere $21,335 per year. However, that same family of four making $130,000 wouldn't qualify for any aid, according to their calculator.
Consequently, for this sample family, Harvard could well cost less than CSU-Los Angeles. Granted, if they are California resident, travel to Massachusetts will likely be more expensive than travel to LA. The education received and the friends made will be significantly different, however.
Net calculators only provide estimates. Those which ask numerous questions have been shown to be fairly accurate.
It pays to do your homework! Evaluate your potential schools' estimated net costs BEFORE you apply. If you need help, search here to find a certified college planning specialist in your area. I work with students all over the USA so can be a resource for you as well.
Katherine O'Brien, MA CCPS
Celtic College Consultants
Based in San Diego, serving families across the USA
www.CelticCollegeConsultants.com
Monday, March 19, 2012
Great Books programs Prepare Industry Leaders
Study of the Great Books is often looked at as a relic of the past, something we can't afford to have our students spend their time on because they need to be employable. This article on community colleges shows the inherent and abiding value of a great books education for the development of business leaders, managers, and industry leaders.
The ability to think critically, consider differing viewpoints, a great deal of information simultaneoulsy, and communicate coherently are all skills honed in the study of the great books. These skills, augmented by knowledge specific to a particular industry, make for a well balanced, effective leader and innovator in that industry.
Many colleges offer Great Books core curricula in addition to major fields of study. Such programs are worthy of serious consideration.
The ability to think critically, consider differing viewpoints, a great deal of information simultaneoulsy, and communicate coherently are all skills honed in the study of the great books. These skills, augmented by knowledge specific to a particular industry, make for a well balanced, effective leader and innovator in that industry.
Many colleges offer Great Books core curricula in addition to major fields of study. Such programs are worthy of serious consideration.
Thursday, March 15, 2012
More and more California Students are seeing the light - and realising that there is life, and there are colleges, outside the Golden State!
A recent LA Times article cites numerous reasons students are leaving California. Increased availability of financial aid is a key factor. For a family with an income of $130,000, Harvard may well be cheaper than CSULA. At Harvard, they will qualify for a great deal of aid, at their local CSU, non. Another, also cost related, factor driving students out of California is the opportunity to finish in four at out of state schools, as opposed to five or six at the heavily impacted California schools (particularly the UC and CSU campuses).
Choosing one's colleges is a critical factor in a successful college education. This year, as in previous years, my clients have been receiving generous scholarship offers from their schools. Student performance is not always excellent. One young man has an extremely uneven academic performance, including a D on his transcript yet has been offered over $65,000 in scholarships by one of his top schools. Another, an honors student, was recently offered $32,500 per year by Case Western.
A recent LA Times article cites numerous reasons students are leaving California. Increased availability of financial aid is a key factor. For a family with an income of $130,000, Harvard may well be cheaper than CSULA. At Harvard, they will qualify for a great deal of aid, at their local CSU, non. Another, also cost related, factor driving students out of California is the opportunity to finish in four at out of state schools, as opposed to five or six at the heavily impacted California schools (particularly the UC and CSU campuses).
Choosing one's colleges is a critical factor in a successful college education. This year, as in previous years, my clients have been receiving generous scholarship offers from their schools. Student performance is not always excellent. One young man has an extremely uneven academic performance, including a D on his transcript yet has been offered over $65,000 in scholarships by one of his top schools. Another, an honors student, was recently offered $32,500 per year by Case Western.
Tuesday, January 31, 2012
Are we surprised that these things happen?
Claremont McKenna admits to inflating their SAT scores for the past 6 years in order to be ranked more highly. A couple of law schools have done the same thing - for more:
http://www.insidehighered.com/quicktakes/2012/01/31/claremont-mckenna-inflated-sat-scores-rankings
Claremont McKenna admits to inflating their SAT scores for the past 6 years in order to be ranked more highly. A couple of law schools have done the same thing - for more:
http://www.insidehighered.com/quicktakes/2012/01/31/claremont-mckenna-inflated-sat-scores-rankings
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)